Self-help Articles

Welcome to the Internet's most trusted self-help & psychology portal, developed by hundreds of volunteers as a labor of love. Since 1994, our licensed
professionals bring you the science of psychology, complete with a worldwide support community. C'mon in - and help yourself!

Butch or Femme - Confused About Gender Stereotypes

Rate this article: None (3 votes)

by Gail S. Bernstein, Ph.D.

 
Question: I've finally admitted to myself that I'm more attracted to women than to men. This is very scary and confusing for me. When I was dating men, most of them expected me to let them take the lead, whether it was to ask for a date, pay the check, initiate sex.
 
Will lesbians expect me to play a male role or a female one? How do I know which I am? I can't go by the things I like: I like to cook and I like to work on my car.
Please help.

The world is full of gender stereotypes, and you're struggling with one of the painful ones.

Contrary to popular myth, most lesbians and gay men don't play either male or female roles in their relationships. Gays and lesbians are just as varied as heterosexuals when it comes to characteristics considered stereotypically feminine or masculine.

There are some lesbians who wear leather and chains, and there are some who wear lipstick and heels. Some are athletic and some do needlework. The more versatile ones engage in activities and dress in ways that might be considered typical in both camps.

The same can be said for gay men, bisexual people, and for heterosexuals of both genders. As the scientific literature grows, it is reflecting more of what is actually out in the world, rather than simply the biases and fears of researchers who dare not report findings that stray from popular, traditional beliefs.

Research on Gender Stereotypes

 As more quality research is reported, we are finding that human sexuality is much more on a continuum, in all ways, from human anatomy, to behavior to preferences within role and fantasies. While traditional psychological research had everyone neatly compartmentalized, the real world is showing that people truly do exist in all shapes, sizes, personalities and behavioral preferences.

Some people prefer to behave differently in different circumstances. They may choose to be a certain way around their families, at home, and quite different with friends, their favorite sport team, at work or at a parent-teacher conference.

Luckily, we can express ourselves in a variety of ways either alone or with different people, and still maintain a core sense of who we are as individuals in the world.

If you feel more comfortable engaging in what is usually thought of as male behavior, that's ok. If you identify as feminine that's fine too. And if prefer a blend of different behaviors in different settings, that's completely acceptable, too.

You may find books like JoAnn Loulan's, The Lesbian Erotic Dance: Butch, Femme, Androgyny and Other Rhythms, helpful. Above all, don't let anyone else dictate your behavior.

What's important is to treat yourself well, regardless of gender stereotypes. Never let yourself sneer or snicker behind someone's back. Smile at them, both when they walk toward you and when they walk away. We all deserve that kind of respect.

About the Author:

Gail S. Bernstein, Ph.D. is an author and psychologist. She has a psychotherapy practice in Denver, Colorado. Dr. Bernstein speaks and writes about gay, lesbian and bisexual people for both general and professional audiences, and is the author of the audiotape, NOT HETEROSEXUAL: An Educational Program About Gay, Lesbian and Bisexual People.

Originally published 3/14/98
Revised 2/18/08 by Marlene M. Maheu, Ph.D.

Has this article helped you
If so please consider helping us - Donate $1

Help support us by making your Amazon purchase here:
SEARCH In Association with Amazon.com
Follow me on Twitter!